Jack In The Box Secret Sauce Recipe ⋆ We Want The Sauce (2024)

If you’re serving burgers, then you need a secret sauce.

Think about it – every burger chain has its secret (or not-so-secret) burger sauce – from McDonald’s to Burger King and even your local mom-and-pop burger joint.

Unfortunately, most taste like Thousand Island dressing with some pickle relish thrown in.

Now don’t get me wrong, I like pickles as much as the next guy.

But there are times I just don’t want them on my burgers.

That’s where thisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipecomes in.

Jack in the Box uses onion instead of pickles in their creamy secret sauce, which makes the Bonus Jack taste so good!

And now you won’t have to run to Jack in the Box the next time you’re craving that savory goodness.

With thisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipe, you can make an authentic-tasting secret sauce right in the comfort of your own kitchen.

Plus, you won’t need any unique ingredients or special equipment to make it. You probably already have everything you’ll need in your fridge and pantry.

And it’s so easy to make, you can have it ready in minutes.

So if you prefer onions over pickle relish on your burgers, you’ll love thisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipe.

What Do You Need To Make Jack In The Box Secret Sauce

Ingredients

Fresh Garlic

Garlic gives your sauce a spicy, nutty flavor that goes great with the other flavors.

You can substitute a teaspoon of garlic powder if you don’t have fresh garlic.

But avoid using garlic salt, or it will overpower your sauce.

Mayonnaise

I always recommend using homemade – nothing else compares to its creaminess and great taste.

However, feel free to use your favorite brand.

And if you like your secret sauce tangy, go ahead and substitute Miracle Whip for the mayo.

Ketchup

Adds the perfect amount of sweetness and tomato flavor.

If you like more tomato flavor, add half a tablespoon of tomato paste.

Prepared Yellow Mustard

Mustard adds a nice tang.

You can change the flavor of your sauce by changing the mustard – Dijon, brown, and honey mustard are all excellent choices.

Apple Cider Vinegar

Vinegar gives your sauce some tang.

Worcestershire Sauce

The umami and savory flavors enhance the taste and add depth to your secret sauce.

Onion Powder

I would usually use fresh onions, but for this recipe, onion powder gives thisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipethe perfect amount of savory onion flavor.

If you’re a purist, go ahead and substitute a small diced onion for the onion powder.

Tabasco Sauce

The hot sauce packs just the right amount of heat.

I like Tabasco sauce for this recipe, but feel free to use your favorite brand.

A1 Steak Sauce

Adds a nice blend of sour and salty taste to your secret sauce.

Salt and Pepper

A little salt and pepper will help unlock the other flavors. But use sparingly, so you don’t overseason your sauce.

Equipment

• Non-reactive mixing bowl
• Spoon or spatula

How To Make Jack In The Box Secret Sauce

ThisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipeis super easy to make.

Step One: Just place all the ingredients in a non-reactive mixing bowl and mix well.

Step Two: Taste your sauce and adjust any ingredients until you get your desired flavor.

Step Three: Season with salt and pepper.

Step Four: Chill in the fridge for at least an hour to allow the flavors to develop.

Step Five: Serve warmed or chilled.

Enjoy!

Other Things To Consider When Making Jack In The Box Secret Sauce

You Can Customize Your Secret Sauce

ThisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipemakes a delicious savory burger sauce.

But with just a couple of easy changes, you can create some great-tasting versions.

For example, add chopped dill pickles or pickle relish to give your secret sauce some tang and texture.

Or substitute balsamic vinegar for the apple cider for a sweeter-tasting Italian-inspired sauce.

If you like it hot, add another teaspoon of hot sauce or a couple of pinches of ground cayenne pepper.

Or, for a sweeter secret sauce, add a teaspoon of honey.

To change the heat, experiment with different hot sauces, like Tapatio or Sriracha.

You’re only limited by your imagination when it comes to discovering delicious new flavors.

So go ahead and experiment. Who knows? You might discover a version that tastes even better than the original.

What Can I Eat with Jack In The Box Secret Sauce?

With its delicious blend of savory and tangy flavors, thisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipemakes the perfect burger sauce.

However, you’ll also enjoy dipping french fries and crispy potato wedges in its creamy goodness.

The flavors go great with batter-fried fish and prawns.

Or use it as a savory sandwich spread rather than plain mayo.

Make More Than You Need!

ThisJack in the Box Secret Sauce recipetastes better the longer it sits.

So go ahead and double the recipe.

Extra sauce will stay fresh in the fridge for up to two weeks in an airtight container.

However, like most mayonnaise-based sauces, I wouldn’t recommend freezing it.

Other related Jack In The Box guides you may want to check out:

• What Sauces Does Jack In The Box Have?
• Jack In The Box Good Good Sauce Recipe
• Jack In The Box Taco Sauce Recipe
• Jack In The Box Teriyaki Sauce Recipe